🆕 Digital Media Listings (Sep 28): The week my open rate tanked

Quick confession. A couple of weeks ago my open rate dropped about 10 points, seemingly overnight. If you're buying or selling newsletters, what I found next is worth knowing.

My first thought was the scary one: had my readers checked out? So I looked past the opens, at the clicks. And here's the twist, the clicks had actually gone up. Fewer "opens," but more people clicking, reading, and engaging across the whole issue. My real audience wasn't shrinking. If anything, it was more active than ever.

So what dropped? The way opens get counted. Open rate is measured by a tiny invisible pixel that loads when your email renders. Apple auto-loads it, previews load it, inbox images load it. But when an email slips into a tab like Gmail's Promotions, those pixels often don't fire, so the "opens" vanish, even though the readers are still right there.

So why did mine slip? Honestly, my recent issues had started sounding a little too salesy, packed with listings, prices, and "deals." That's exactly what nudges an email out of the inbox and into the Promotions tab. My readers hadn't changed; my emails had just started looking like ads.

And that's the real lesson, the one we come back to every time we value a newsletter: no single number tells the whole story. Open rate alone would've had me thinking my list was dying. Clicks told the opposite. It's only when you look at the full picture, opens, clicks, replies, revenue, growth, churn, where the subscribers came from, that you see what a newsletter is really worth.

It's exactly how we value here. We never price a list off one stat. We look at a whole set of signals together, because any one of them on its own can lie. The truth lives in the combination.

So whether you're buying or selling: don't let one metric make or break a deal. Zoom out. The whole picture is the only one that tells the truth.

Curious what your newsletter is worth? Our valuation tool weighs the whole picture, not just one number. Try it here →

A great sale closed on LetterTrader: an AI newsletter with 304,000 subscribers, making around $5,500 a month, found a buyer this week.

Before I tell you what it went for, take a guess. (Fun fact: back in August, when I asked what you'd pay for a big AI list, most of you said $30–75K.)

The answer's waiting at the very bottom. 👇

Congratulations to all parties involved!

Find the perfect digital asset to acquire. 🌍 Website | 🗞️ Newsletter | 🧑‍🤝‍🧑 Community | 🎧 Podcast | 📱 Application

You should know by now that I love a good poll/quizz!

Atrivial is a new tool that makes them effortless: paste your content, and it spins up a quiz or poll, hosted and ready to drop into your email.

You get real data on what your readers actually want and a cleaner way to bring in sponsors.

(I will use this tool in the next issues.) Let me know your thoughts on it.

And if you want to try it for your newsletter

→ Try Atrivial —> Get 10% off + 30-day trial with code LT10.

🐝 beehiiv — 20% off your first 3 months on one of the best newsletter platforms out there. Get started.

✍️ Newsletter Copilot — A human writing partner that supports, advises, and helps with your newsletter growth. Try it.

🤝 Lettergrowth — Cross-promote with creators in your niche and grow your audience for FREE. Start now.

👑 Empire Flippers — The marketplace to acquire or sell a SaaS or eCommerce business. Browse.

🏠 Bilt — Earn points on rent with no fees, the card that pays you back for a bill you already have. Get yours.

Future Blueprint sold for $110,000. If you guessed lower, you're in good company, back in August most of you valued a big AI list at $30–75K. But the right buyer saw what the metrics alone don't: a 304,000-strong, engaged AI audience is worth more than its monthly revenue suggests. Which is exactly this week's lesson, the whole picture beats any single number.